Operational Excellence Case Study: When Assembly Spends More Time Searching Than Assembling
Case study of a mid-sized manufacturer of customer-specific industrial components: through a reorganization of assembly, the productivity of the assembly staff was more than doubled.
The starting position in 30 seconds
Situation. The company is a mid-sized industrial business in the German-speaking region that produces customer-specific components for industrial applications. The product range comprises many variants; the products partly contain electronics and are configured and tested for each order. Volumes amount to a few hundred units per variant and year. Assembly is carried out manually at individual workstations by qualified skilled workers.
Complication. Assembly was the bottleneck: delivery dates were postponed and order backlogs increased. The use of available assembly time was not transparent. Assemblers were responsible for all activities – from fetching material in the warehouse through assembly to testing. Production took place in batches, material was spread across several areas of the building, and missing parts were only identified at the workbench when an order was started.
Solution. Before any decision on additional capacity, the use of time in assembly was first measured. On this basis, assembly was reorganized: work preparation was stabilized, value-adding and logistics activities were separated, and assemblies and workstations were aligned with flow.
The project was part of a broader restructuring. This state is characterized by fewer problems being solved per unit of time than new ones arising. Operational deficits become visible at the customer first – in the form of missed delivery dates – while their causes lie in the organization of processes.
The diagnosis: work sampling
A work sampling study was conducted at all assembly workstations as the diagnostic instrument. At short, random intervals, the activity performed at each workstation is recorded: assembling, testing, searching for material, fetching parts, reworking or waiting. The method requires no time measurement of individual employees and provides a reliable data basis within a few days.
The analysis showed a share of value-adding activity of only around 40 % at individual workstations. The remaining share was accounted for by gathering parts, sorting batches, clarifying missing material and rework. The causes therefore lay predominantly in the organization rather than in employee performance.
The capacity question was consequently less a question of headcount than of time utilization.
Lever 1: Stabilization of work preparation
Missing parts cause standstill regardless of how a workstation is designed. The measures therefore started upstream of assembly: routings and bills of material were maintained in the ERP system, replenishment lead times were set realistically and material availability was made transparent for each order. As a result, planning was stabilized and orders were handed over to assembly with complete material.
Lever 2: Separation of value-adding work and logistics
The supply of raw material and pre-kitted components to the workstation was transferred to internal logistics. Non-value-adding activities were thus shifted from the skilled assemblers to employees whose core task is material supply. Both areas were able to concentrate on their respective tasks.
Lever 3: Conversion from batch production to flow
The products were broken down into assemblies; for each assembly, a dedicated workstation with suitable tools and semi-automated fixtures was set up. Batch production was replaced by a flow in which each part passes through the stations in sequence. Final testing was automated. At peak load, a station can be reinforced by a second assembler without changes to the workflow.
In addition, 5S workshops were held at the workstations and the material flow was reorganized – from goods receipt via inspection, storage and picking to assembly, final testing and shipping. Defined staging areas for picked orders, finished goods and blocked stock make bottlenecks immediately visible, for example when a picked order is waiting for a missing part.

The results
- Productivity of the assembly staff more than doubled.
- Higher share of value-adding activity among skilled assemblers.
- Early visibility of bottlenecks ahead of the delivery date.
- Documented standards for workstations, material supply and processes.
The sequence of measures was decisive for the impact: material availability and planning first, followed by workstation design and flow. Without reliable material supply, improvements at the workstation remain ineffective.
Three key takeaways
- Measurement before investment. A work sampling study requires only a few days of effort and shows whether a capacity bottleneck or an organizational problem exists.
- Deploy skilled workers on value-adding work. Consistently separating material supply from assembly increases available assembly capacity.
- Productivity starts in work preparation. Without stable planning and reliable material availability, the effect of improvements at the workstation remains limited.
Note: This case study is based on a real 10-P Consult engagement. The client's name and identifying details have been anonymized or generalized.
Further articles:
On-Time Delivery Case Study: When the Plan Doesn't Account for People (link)
Peak Performance through Transparency (Part 1 / 2) (link)
Defining KPIs: How a Business Goal Becomes a KPI That Management Trusts (link)
Where does your company stand?
Is your company facing similar challenges? The Quick Health Check takes five minutes to complete and shows which state your company is in and which fields of action offer the greatest leverage – as a five-page profile, reviewed by an experienced consultant and free of charge.
Start the Quick Health Check

